In the prologue of The Fifth Season, this was too much. Intrigued? Then itâ€™s time for Mark to read The Broken Earth.
Trigger Warning: For death of a child
Oh, what a day. WHAT A DAY, friends.
First things first: Inevitably, as is the case when I start a new book or series on my sites, there is an influx of newbies! I review books slightly differently than folks are used to, so I encourage new folks to read this to understand how things work around here. This time, however, I would recommend returning readers to give this a look, too, as there is a big change this time around.Â
Please do not spoil me or anyone else. While I have extensively written about what constitutes a spoiler in myÂ RulesÂ andÂ FAQÂ pages, there is a very,Â veryÂ simple way of abiding by this: if what you are about to say inÂ anyÂ way refers to something I have not reached yet, donâ€™t say it in plaintext. Just donâ€™t. You donâ€™t need to say it to me, I will survive to live another day,Â donâ€™t.
You may use rot13 to discuss spoilers, however. The gibberish in the comments isÂ rot13, a cyphering tool that you can use to openly discuss all spoilers. Have at it!
Please read myÂ Site RulesÂ before you participate in the comments. Aside from myÂ Spoiler Policy, I also enforce a fairly rigorous set of standards for my community. I have a lot of moderators (who have blue IntenseDebate bars) that may ask you not to use a word or phrase, who may edit a spoiler, or who may delete a comment outright. They are volunteers trying to make this place safe and the exception to the rule for Internet commenting. Please treat them with respect or you will lose your commenting privileges.
If you missed the announcement (as is probably the case if you werenâ€™t checking in during my Discworld read), health issues have necessitated that I stop doing Mark Reads videos in order to not harm my voice. From here on out, weâ€™re going back to the original style of Mark Reads reviews, which are all text. Please donâ€™t try to commission video readings of the books Iâ€™m covering anymore; I will promptly refund you. (If youâ€™re reading this and have an outstanding commission, please check your email, as I contacted you already! About 75% of folks have already responded, so there are a few people still left.)
That being said: Mark Reads canâ€™t make any money right now aside from the pocket change I make from ads. Mark Watches keeps this place going, so if youâ€™re digging this project and youâ€™d like to support me, you can sign up for my Patreon, where I post reviews early, give folks a behind-the-scenes look of publishing, host a Slack, and do monthly bonus commissions. You can also check out the â€œSupport Markâ€ menu above for other options!
In 2015, when I was at Arisia in Boston, N.K. Jemisin was the guest of honor. I was in the room for a reading of hers and heard what I think was the prologue of this book? All of this was deeply unfamiliar to me except for I remember it being about rocks and that it was in second person? Either way: I do like being upfront about knowing literally ANYTHING about a project, since being unspoiled is the whole point of this. So, I still donâ€™t know shit about this trilogy, and Iâ€™m scared.
Because lord, did The Inheritance Trilogy ruin me. RUIN. ME. (You can find the complete archive of those reviews here!)
So, itâ€™s really fun and exciting to be returning to the work of N.K. Jemisin, someone who I look up to and respect. But I also approach this (and really, everything I write about on Mark Reads especially) from a different perspective. By the time I finished The Inheritance Trilogy, I was still hard at work on a novel of my own, one at the time was science fiction and part of a greater plan for a trilogy. (I LOVE TRILOGIES.) It didnâ€™t turn out that way, but what Iâ€™d planned for a LOT of things didnâ€™t turn out as I expected. I say this because I now have something I never thought Iâ€™d write coming out this fall: a fantasy book. I promise, this is not about promoting myself, but sharing that I understand something because Iâ€™ve now been on the other side of the curtain.
Holy fucking shit, fantasy books are HARD TO WRITE.Â
And itâ€™s not like the other books Iâ€™ve written were necessarily easy, but there is just so much more you have to do and take into consideration than I thought I was ready for. As I read the opening sentences of the prologue, as Jemisin slipped us all into the world of the Stillness, I could appreciate what a delicate, complicated, and masterful thing had just been accomplished. The first page alone is phenomenal, and what a way to open a book: with an ending. A cataclysmic one, too, all so we could get on to better things? Entire books, trilogies, movements, longform series have been devoted to the notion of the end of the world. Jemisin starts with it.
Itâ€™s a weird fucking thing to be reading on May 31, 2020, too.
From there, thereâ€™s a monumental task set forth, one I found increasingly difficult to manage myself. Look, in a fantasy narrative, the reader needs to know about the world. They need to know whatâ€™s different from our world, or whatâ€™s the same. Is it a secondary world? Contemporary? A portal to a new realm? How does any of it work? And by â€œit,â€ I meanâ€¦ well, literally every aspect of a society or a community or a world. Except you canâ€™t know everything, right? A writer has to choose what has meaning, what matters to the story, what remains in the background, what sits in the forefront. Whatâ€™s the context that informs the decisions of major characters?
All that is still the tip of the iceberg. Whatâ€™s the framing device, then, by which an author can reveal this information? A lot of fantasy books do this thing where this expositionâ€”which is necessary, to some extentâ€”is dumped upon the reader. Iâ€™ve read books in the past year where these info dumps are the first fifty pages, and itâ€™s a challenge to read through them! I understand that there has to be some form of onboarding when it comes to many of the speculative fiction genres, but I also want to be intrigued. Entertained. I need to care.
Look how quickly Jemisin introduces a character, gives us an emotional conflict IN THE SECOND PARAGRAPH, and makes it very clear what sort of tone weâ€™re getting here. I donâ€™t mean that solely in terms of emotional heaviness; on the second page, itâ€™s also obvious that the narration is going to be very different from one might expect from a fantasy novel. Iâ€™m a huge fan of voice-y novels, and look at the voice of this narrator! I donâ€™t know if theyâ€™re a character weâ€™ll meet at some point. They could be an interested third party. They could be.. no one. Just the narrator. But oh, I love it. The use of second-person intrigues me, too. I canâ€™t tell what Jemisin is doing with it to accent the story, but something feels more than intentional about it. Someone is telling this story to someone, giving them bits and pieces that are important, that provide context, that ground this story in a long history. Soâ€¦ who is The Fifth Season speaking to? Why does that matter?
The brilliance of this riskâ€”because second-person is exceedingly rareâ€”is that it allows Jemisin to provide exposition in a stylistic, poetic way for the reader and whomever is intended as the recipient of the narratorâ€™s story. (Which still could be us, now that I think about it. Oh, Iâ€™m in for a ride, arenâ€™t I?) And while this narration is lyrical and gorgeous, I also love that Jemisin plays with the notion of the literal and the metaphorical. There is a boldness in declaring a detail like a balcony to be a sign of defiance, for example. Literally, they make no sense in a world like the Stillness, and yet that one bit says so much. How do people defy the geological nature of their world? Is it safe to assume that there is an element of luxury in this, that it winks at the reader and tells us that this is what the privileged do? They build in defiance of what is sensible because they can. It speaks in a metaphorical sense about what it means to live in Yumenes, one of the equatorial cities that is stable only relative to the rest of the land.Â
Yet later, Jemisin toys with metaphor very directly:Â
Up close, however, any hypothetical observer would notice that her skin is white porcelain; that is not a metaphor. As a sculpture, she would be beautiful, if too relentlessly realistic for local tastes. Most Yumenescenes prefer polite abstraction over vulgar actuality.
Because thereâ€™s the direct rejection of a metaphor in that passage, and yet, the image means something else. What does realism mean to the people of Yemenes? Why do they prefer abstraction over actuality?Â
What donâ€™t the Yemenes want to see?
So, thereâ€™s a beautiful use of language throughout this, one thatâ€™s having a direct conversation and another between the lines. With this, Jemisin paints a picture of a world about to end: of how Yemenes constructed high in defiance of a constantly-moving world, and yet, everything comes to an end. Thereâ€™s an end in Ucheâ€™s life, and thereâ€™s an end in the emperor. Thereâ€™s an end in Yemenes. And itâ€™s all because of an unknown man who has a connection to this world that I donâ€™t quite understand. From context, Iâ€™m thinking that â€œsessapinaeâ€ is something in the manâ€™s body, and itâ€™s how he sense other life, maybe? Regardless: we know his companion has existed since basically the beginning of time, and she is here to witness what is about to pass.Â
She is also a stone eater.
(Is that what the creature is at the end of the prologue?)
This is the end of the world. Something I assume the stone eaters, who live belowground, have seen over and over again. Why did this one seek out the man who ended the world? And what does this mean?
His fingers spread and twitch as he feels several reverberating points on the map of his awareness: his fellow slaves. He cannot free them, not in the practical sense. Heâ€™s tried before and failed. He can, however, make their suffering serve a cause greater than one cityâ€™s hubris, and one empireâ€™s fear.Â
This is a weird fucking thing to be reading on May 31, 2020.Â
One thing that stuck out to me in this prologue was how debris and hubris seem so close to one another in this world. The people of Yemenes constructed a city that stretched to the skyâ€”that had balconies!â€”even though there is no certain other than the world eventually tearing itself apart. So, in the world that comes next, will the rubble of Yemenes be like the obelisks that float in the sky? Will it be stripped of meaning in the eons that come and pass? Will people wonder what was once there, and will they event stories to explain it? This book is, indeed, another story being told about this place. How many more will be added?
After all this, though, Jemisin narrows the focus, and we fully meet Essun, Ucheâ€™s mother. I might be misreading this, but there seems to be some sort of in-world similarity to colorism happening here, given how Essunâ€™s skin is described:
Her skin is unpleasantly ocher-brown by some standards and unpleasantly olive-pale by others.
The use of the word â€œunpleasantlyâ€ is fascinating. Whose standards? Why do some look down on her for dark skin? Why do others see her as too pale? Even more interesting:
Mongrel midlatters, Yumenescenes call (called) people like herâ€”enough Sanzed in them to show, not enough to tell.
Thatâ€™s an intentional term, one meant to invoke a very real-world slur. So whatâ€™s â€œSanzedâ€? Another people? How does that affect her appearance?
She liked nursing Uche here. She thinks he was conceived here.
His father has beaten him to death here.
Hi, what the fuck. Hello???? Why are you doing this to me???
But thereâ€™s one more enormous twist here, and itâ€™s the object. The object that appears in the remains outside of Tirimo, Essunâ€™s home. The object thatâ€¦ births? Someone?? Who also isnâ€™t a child??? Who eats the crystals from inside the object? Except now Iâ€™m re-thinking the use of â€œappears.â€ Was that thing always in Tirimo, or did it arrive after the quakes? WHY IS HE TRYING TO MIMIC BEING HUMAN???
As if all this werenâ€™t enough, I canâ€™t get over the final line of the prologue:
This is the way the world ends.Â
For the last time.
If the end of the world is this seismic upheaval, one caused by the unnamed man earlier in the prologue, thenâ€¦ whatâ€™s coming? What upsets that cycle? Essun? The strange character who is imitating a human boy? Something else?
This feels so appropriate, yâ€™all. Beginnings and endings. The story opens with the end of the world, and here, at the end of this introduction, we get a glimpse of where it will all go.Â
Itâ€™s fucking brilliant, and I, for one, cannot wait to find out what all of this.
Since there are no longer videos, I wanted to bring back something I did irregularly back when I did Mark Reads without that aspect. The videos achieved a neat thing: yâ€™all got to see instantaneous reactions to things. But you also got all my asides, many of which never made it into reviews. I was always conscious of this notion of keeping them separate: they were each their own form of criticism, in a sense, so I didnâ€™t want my reviews to just be a repeat of the video.
This is the first review Iâ€™ve written sinceâ€¦ shit. 2012? 2013? Somewhere around then was when Mark Reads videos were introduced. What I used to do was read with my Notes app open, and Iâ€™d put all my preliminary thoughts and reactions into it. Some of this stuff made it into the final review, as youâ€™ll see below! Some of it didnâ€™t. Either way, you can enjoy this stream-of-conscious nightmare, as I plan to include these at the end of every review.Â
Thanks for being here with me, friends.
- hey that dedication HELL YEAH
- fuck yeah MAPS i wanna write a book with a map someday
- hi, reading this on may 31, 2020 is a fucking LOT
- conflict between fantasy and reality re: uche?
- love how many of these descriptions are both poetic AND literal
- oh my god balconies as bravery and hubris
- â€œbecause why notâ€ LMMMAAAOOOOO
- LITERALLY PRESERVED??? WHAT???
- sessapinae? dictionary is failing me
- feeling?? what? who is his companion???
- â€œthat is not a metaphorâ€ I LOVE HOW THIS TEXT PLAYS WITH THIS NOTION
- stone eaters???
- what the fuck who is this guy!!!
- the second person is SO FUCKING GOOD.
- debris as history?
- thereâ€™s an interesting whimsy to the narration
- the way different cities are built based on where they are in the Stillness!!!!!
- the past tense asides HELP, THEY RUIN ME
- what the FUCK
- I DONâ€™T LIKE THE OBJECT
- N O P E
- â€œsomething pushes the object from withinâ€ absolutely fucking not
- â€œnot actually a childâ€ hey why are you like this
- for the last time??? hey WHAT
Mark Links Stuff
– You can now pre-order my second YA novel, Each of Us a Desert, which will be released on September 15, 2020 from Tor Teen!
– Not only that, but my very first pre-order campaign is now live for North American readers! If you submit proof of pre-order, you can get a limited edition print that comes with the book.
– If you’d like to stay up-to-date on all announcements regarding my books, sign up for my newsletter! DO IT.